Due to her feeling small, Hilda and Zelda try to make her feel better by telling her about their mistakes over the years.
She gets her wish with a can of worms but discovers a soap opera life isn't all it's cracked up to be. As Westbridge Turns: Sabrina wishes her life was more like the soap operas she sees on TV.Meeting Dad's Girlfriend: Ted Spellman pays Sabrina and her aunts a visit but things become tricky when his new girlfriend Gail comes into the picture.Cat Showdown: Sabrina enters Salem in a cat show, only to discover one of the other contestants is blackmailing the judge into making their cat the winner.Sabrina bonds with a kindly old lady called Nana, only for things to turn sour when Libby shows up. Sweet Charity: Sabrina, Harvey and Jenny visit an old folks home as part of a charity program.First Kiss: It's Valentine's Day but Sabrina discovers a witch's first kiss with a mortal will turn him into a frog.Mars Attracts!: The Spellmans head to a ski resort on Mars for a weekend vacation but Sabrina meets a boy who puts her relationship with Harvey to the test.
As a compromise they turn themselves into teenagers to supervise her but it turns out they aren't as mature as they think they are.
When neither of her aunts can reason with him, a vengeance spell puts him on trial for being mean and unfair to his students. Trial by Fury: Sabrina fails a math test set by the mean and unfair Mr Rockwell.A Girl and Her Cat: After ruining Sabrina's Christmas date with Harvey, Salem ends up trapped in the room of a young boy who refuses to let him go.All this makes Sabrina's trophy call her a cheater, so she decides to redeem herself against the runner-up.
Sweet & Sour Victory: Sabrina uses magic on herself to make her a kung-fu expert and win a tournament.But Libby still acts the same despite her new look. Geek Like Me: To get back at Libby, Sabrina casts a spell that makes her become a nerd and eat some humble pie.Magic Joel: A teen magician hires Sabrina to be his assistant for his vanishing act, only for her to make him invisible for real.Third Aunt from the Sun: In the first script written by Salem's voice actor Nick Bakay, hedonistic Aunt Vesta takes advantage of Sabrina's frustration with Hilda and Zelda.Dream Date: Disappointed that Harvey is taken for the school dance, Sabrina settles for a boy made out of dough.A Halloween Story: Sabrina makes a duplicate of herself to send to Harvey's Halloween party while she attends a witches' Halloween dinner party and puts up with her troublesome younger cousin Amanda.Terrible Things: Sabrina helps others out with magic despite warnings from Salem and the aunts that doing so can lead to terrible things.Meanwhile, her aunts Hilda and Zelda attend parent-teacher conference night. However, she accidentally enchants him to grow up into a middle-aged man with the mind of a baby. The True Adventures of Rudy Kazootie: To buy a real pair of roller-skates (since spells result in knock-off brands), Sabrina offers to babysit the neighbors' toddler son.
Episode recaps for the 1990s Sabrina the Teenage Witch TV series.